Eh... is it arguing for the sake of argument? :) I do not believe ever mentioning in my comments that the beauty would safe the world or non-violent demonstration is our only hope. Read my comments more carefully, pls. I do, however, applaud people who are willing to risk their lives to protect civilians during armed conflicts or wars.
But back to your scenario, which, for the record, i support. What, in your point of view, is the definition of the victory in such situation?